Time for insurers to review claims handling and management processes
By Michael Bracken, principal at McCabes Lawyers’ financial services and financial institutions practice
On October 9, the Federal Court held that Hollard Insurance Partners (formerly CommInsure, which it had acquired from CBA on September 30 2022) had breached its duty of utmost good faith to an insured arising from significant delays, poor communication and other defaults in handling a home insurance claim.
Significantly, Hollard was ordered to pay a $2 million penalty.
In imposing the penalty, Justice Catherine Button emphasised that: “It is incumbent on insurers to ensure that their claims handling accords with the duty of utmost good faith. Hollard’s contravening conduct here fell well short of that standard.”
Duty of utmost good faith in context of claims management
The duty of utmost good faith in section 13 of the Insurance Contracts Act is implied into every contract of consumer insurance and requires an insurer to act fairly, honestly and reasonably towards insureds.
This means that, when handling claims, an insurer must not act capriciously or unreasonably, nor disregard the interests of the insured. In practice, a failure to comply with this duty may manifest as undue delay, failure to provide timely decisions on liability, inadequate communication or withholding information, or unreasonable refusal of a claim or to co-operate concerning claim handling.
Nature of claims handling delays and failures
Hollard admitted seven separate delays and failures in handling claims and communicating with insureds between November 15 2021 and April 28 2023. These included delays in engaging a structural engineer, arranging further emergency works, providing temporary accommodation and repairing mould, as well as failing to properly consider expert reports and to clearly explain the basis and value of its cash settlement offer.
Notably, the contravention did not arise from a one-off bad decision, oversight or error but it “arose from conduct over an overall long period of time, and arose from multiple instances of lack of attention, delay and a lack of alacrity in progressing claims handling”.
Justice Button held that Hollard failed to meet industry standards such as the General Insurance Industry Code of Practice.
The penalty imposed arose from a single contravention relating to a single policy. Hollard admitted that its serious claim handling failures resulted in a Victorian family living in appalling conditions, with their home ultimately deemed a total loss.
The penalty
In the court’s view, the prolonged period of the default and the multiple failures to manage the insureds’ claim for indemnity under the policy required a penalty that factored in a message of deterrence.
Hollard admitted it failed to comply with the duty implied into the policy by section 13(1). Therefore, it contravened section 13(2A).
In calculating the civil penalty specified under 13(2A), the court applied section 75D, which provides for higher pecuniary penalties for a body corporate, with the maximum penalty to be worked out based on the 10% of the annual turnover formula specified by section 75D(2)(c)(i).
The parties agreed the maximum penalty was $81.6 million, being 10% of Hollard’s annual turnover for the 12-month period beginning November 2021, when the contravention began.
On this basis, Justice Button decided “a penalty of $2 million will send a message to insurers that the duty of utmost good faith is real; it is not an empty verbal formula. Rather, it is a substantive, and reciprocal, obligation between insurers and insureds. It is one that attaches to claims handling as much as other matters relating to the contract of insurance.”
The court factored in Hollard’s full co-operation with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission during the proceedings and the remedial steps it had taken subsequent to the breach of duty to improve practices, processes and governance relating to claims processing, including reducing staff-to-claims ratios and implementing integrated claims systems to prevent recurrence of a breach.
Importance of the code
Justice Button said: “Hollard was a signatory to the General Insurance Code of Practice, the relevant paragraphs of which (as applicable during the relevant period) included obligations to correct mistakes promptly, to progress and communicate about claims within defined time frames, to engage suitably qualified external experts, and to make a decision within four months (or, in defined circumstances, 12 months).”
Significantly, on October 22, the Insurance Council of Australia submitted a revised code to ASIC for regulatory approval. Under proposed amendments to the revised code, certain provisions will form part of the insurance policy itself and thus a breach of the code will directly equate to a breach of contract.
The revised code provides:
- A proposed uplift in protections for consumers including enhanced expectations for trauma-informed claims handling and strengthened requirements for primary points of contact and cash settlements.
- Industry principles which include “managing claims in line with our obligations under the code and the law”.
Therefore, enforceability of these revised code provisions will result in extra-contractual standards becoming a binding contractual obligation.
This means that, in addition to the broader remedies already available under the Insurance Contracts Act for breach of the duty of utmost good faith:
- Policyholders (and potentially ASIC as regulator) may have recourse to contractual remedies including damages arising from an insurer’s failure to meet code obligations relating to claims handling and settlement.
- Courts may in the future set additional benchmarks for assessing conduct against both the code and statutory standards.
This is likely to bolster ASIC’s enforcement priority to address claims handling failures and to potentially encourage remedies for a contractual as well as statutory breach. For example, the presence of contractually binding code provisions would have underscored the seriousness of Hollard’s failures and further justified both compensatory and deterrent remedies.
Ten steps
Some risk management and governance steps insurers and claims teams might consider in response to the evolving legal risks from the Hollard case and the revised code are:
- Audit claims time frames and communications against section 13 Insurance Contracts Act expectations (timeliness, clarity of reasons, documented decision-making and updates).
- Adopt explicit time frames for claim decisions consistent with the code’s requirements.
- Accurate record-keeping and tracking of the date of claims decisions.
- Strengthen procedures for identifying and supporting vulnerable customers and customers experiencing financial hardship.
- Strengthen governance over third-party claims providers, ensuring accountability and escalation protocols (including for make-safe failures and accommodation); service supply contracts should reflect the revised code’s standards.
- Implement controls for expert engagement and evidence review, with checklists to ensure reports are considered in the context of relevant facts, policy terms, the law and the scope of settlement offers.
- Stress test surge capacity and staffing ratios to reduce delay risk, particularly for weather/disaster events.
- Review code compliance exposure (including potential future contractual enforceability) and update training and templates for communications to ensure all communications are made in plain language and are tailored to support consumers including cash settlement. Identify and comply with any enforceable provisions, which may attract civil penalties for non-compliance.
- Immediately correct claims handling mistakes and system failures, including proactive remediation to address deficiencies identified in Australian Financial Complaints Authority determinations and early engagement with ASIC. Complaint data should be recorded and analysed to drive continuous improvement systems to capture and report code breaches.
- Align internal dispute resolution processes with the code and ASIC regulatory guidance.