Brought to you by:

Former Chubb chief alleges he was 'fired for speaking up'

Chubb’s previous country president for Australia and New Zealand, Ben Howell, has alleged he was fired without warning after speaking up about what he describes as misleading accounting practices. 

As previously reported, Mr Howell has begun proceedings in the Federal Court following his sudden exit from the company in April. 

Mr Howell says in a statement of claim now filed with the court that he and other Chubb staff were instructed not to disclose or refer to inconsistencies resulting from the accounting practices when explaining financial reports. 

“I was not willing to effectively lie,” he says in a statement provided to insuranceNEWS.com.au. “I was not prepared to provide false financial narratives, or have the company make investment and people decisions based on inaccurate performance measures." 

The statement of claim alleges the accounting practice involved recognising written insurance premium from contracts when they were processed in Chubb’s system, rather than when contracts became legally enforceable.  

This practice led to accounting inconsistencies and allowed Chubb to manipulate the timing of when written premium was recognised, directly benefiting several senior executives by enabling them to align premium with business targets to maximise entitlements to performance bonuses and promotion potential, Mr Howell says. 

Mr Howell says he raised concerns with senior executives and refused requests to give what he calls false and misleading financial performance explanations. He says he was told he should not “swim against the tide”. 

He says on April 2, after a further request to explain financial reports without disclosing, or referring to inconsistencies arising from the practices, he sent an email with information from his finance team that explained the performance of Chubb, including reference to the accounting impact. 

Twelve days later he was fired without warning, the claim alleges. 

Mr Howell says he was previously promoted and routinely received positive performance reviews, including in the weeks before his termination, and was highly regarded in the market. 

“My desire was to raise and resolve my concerns internally within the Chubb Group, and I never imagined that by speaking up in support of my people and business, I would end up in this position,” he says. “I am very saddened that by speaking up and telling the truth it has come to this.” 

Chubb Insurance Australia is listed as the respondent in the action, along with some executives and board members. Mr Howell is represented by Harmers Workplace Lawyers. 

Chubb has been contacted for comment. The insurer has not yet filed a defence to the claims.

When Mr Howell launched the action, a Chubb spokesperson said that "as the matter is before the court, it would be inappropriate to comment at this time”.