Mustang dally: driver compensated over long road to repair
An insurer has been told to pay compensation to a motorist after it took nine months to repair his Ford Mustang following a crash.
Suncorp did not satisfactorily manage delays or keep the policyholder informed, the industry ombudsman has found.
The Mustang was just six months old when it was involved in a crash in September last year.
Suncorp accepted the claim and authorised repairs, but the policyholder said the car should have been treated as a total loss.
He turned to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, arguing “a near-new high-performance vehicle is bought with an expectation of reliability, safety and preserved value” and major repairs including an engine replacement, could “affect the vehicle’s resale value because future buyers may question the long-term reliability of those repairs”.
However, these concerns do not mean the vehicle was a total loss under the policy or relevant law, AFCA says.
“The test is whether the vehicle was unsafe or uneconomical to repair.”
The ombudsman finds the repair decision consistent with the policy and NSW law. The repair estimate was $28,480 while the vehicle’s agreed value was $95,000. Even with salvage value included, the combined amount was well below the insured value.
But AFCA acknowledges the owner’s complaints about the time taken to complete the repairs.
It says parts ordered in October were not received until February, a delay of more than three months.
AFCA says the insurer did not adequately investigate whether parts could be sourced sooner or clearly explain reasons for the delay. The policyholder was also given changing and unclear information about the repair progress.
The ombudsman has awarded $3000 for stress and inconvenience, rejecting Suncorp’s earlier $1000 goodwill offer.
It also says the policyholder qualified for hire car cover as a no-fault driver, despite the insurer’s argument he had not bought the optional insurance.
Suncorp must also meet the reasonable cost of an independent assessment by the policyholder’s preferred Ford dealer. An earlier inspection identified a possible exhaust leak and an unsecured engine wiring harness, and if the further assessment identifies incomplete or defective repairs, the insurer must pay for the necessary work.
See the ruling here.