Brought to you by:

One in the eye: cyclone shutdown fails to trigger BI payout

A Gold Coast restaurant that closed as Cyclone Alfred approached has lost a business interruption dispute because authorities did not directly prevent or hinder access to its premises.

The business was based in a shopping centre that sent a March 5 2025 notice saying the city council advised residents to take shelter by 6pm and stay indoors until Alfred passed. The centre said it would be shut on March 6 and 7, with further updates to come.

The company said its closure was not voluntary and resulted from a public authority’s direction, and that transport shutdowns and emergency measures across the region restricted movement and access to the premises.

Insurer Suncorp accepted part of the restaurant and hospitality company’s claim related to property damage, but it declined the BI component under a “prevention of access by a legal authority” clause.

It said authorities had issued general advice focused on public safety and had not directly prevented or hindered use of the premises, and that its policy covered the threat of damage “only within a 50km radius” of the premises.

Related article: Off-road racer’s crash claim ditched after disqualifying lap

The threat from Cyclone Alfred in the days before landfall extended from the Sunshine Coast in Queensland through to northern NSW, which “clearly exceeded” the radius.

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority says the warnings were serious, but available information does not establish that a government, public or statutory authority directed the centre or the business to close.

Nor is the ombudsman satisfied an authority’s action hindered access to the premises within the policy meaning. There is no evidence staff or customers depended on suspended transport services or closed roads, or that the premises could not otherwise be reached.

Warnings and transport measures were issued in response to Alfred risks that extended across a substantial geographic area, and it was not established that authorities acted because of potential damage confined to only property within the radius of the premises, the ombudsman says.

“The policy does not cover lost income where the business closes due to inclement weather or safety concerns. The complainant has not met the requirements of any insuring provision, and so is not entitled to cover.”

The decision is here.