Brought to you by:

Fired Chubb boss claims up to $64m for future income loss

Chubb’s former Australia and New Zealand chief Ben Howell is seeking compensation for financial losses that could total more than $60 million, a statement of claim shows.

Mr Howell has alleged in Federal Court documents that he was fired from the country president role without warning after speaking up about what he calls misleading accounting practices.

The statement of claim, seen by insuranceNEWS.com.au, says the termination has affected his career and he will probably have to accept lower remuneration of between $400,000 and $800,000 in future, with promotion opportunities limited.

A future financial loss of between $7.85 million and $64.3 million is likely, and a lost opportunity for performance-based payments since April is estimated at $2.2 million, according to the statement.

Non-economic impacts, including from anxiety and distress, are asserted and Chubb should pay a Fair Work Act penalty to Mr Howell, the claim says.

Mr Howell says Chubb recognised written premium revenue after it was processed internally, rather than on the date a contract became enforceable, meaning timings could be manipulated.

He claims the “calendarisation” practice enabled employees to align revenue with business targets to maximise entitlements to bonuses and promotion potential.

The practice affected 2025 financial figures and premium, while growth for the 2026 first quarter appeared lower when in fact the performance improved, the statement says.

An email from an Asia-Pacific executive suggested the region was under pressure, with an “APAC Q1M2” forecast “not well received”, according to the claim. The email said Australia and New Zealand calendarisation issues reported over five quarters were “starting to create serious damage” to credibility and to refrain from using that explanation going forward.

At a March 23 2026 meeting, Mr Howell disputed that the underlying business had issues, saying it outperformed the Australian commercial insurance sector in 2025 and a distortion affected the first quarter related to previous reporting of $70 million in premium.

He also later said a significant amount of premium had travelled “from the first quarter of 2026 into the fourth quarter of 2025 and then from the second quarter of 2026 into the first quarter of 2026”.

He said a 9.3% decline in premium growth for the quarter was an amount less booked, not less business written, and reporting practices could “mislead business decisions”.

Mr Howell says that at a March 30 meeting, he was told a first-quarter explanation was needed for group CEO Evan Greenberg and “the street”, with the Australian decline a big impact as part of property and casualty, while later messages said not to mention calendarisation.

He says he sent an April 2 email to the Chubb property and casualty division president explaining the financial performance “truthfully” as provided by his finance team, including reference to calendarisation.

At an April 14 meeting, Mr Howell was told he was “being terminated because of performance in 2025 and the first quarter of 2026”, the statement says.

His own performance in the 2025 calendar and financial years was rated as “achieving expectations” in his formal review in February 2026 and feedback to the board was positive, the statement says.

Chubb is defending the proceedings.

“Chubb takes all such claims seriously,” a spokesperson told insuranceNEWS.com.au.

“Therefore, upon these claims being received, Chubb initiated an independent external forensic accounting review. This investigation found that the claims are without merit. We are vigorously defending these claims.”

The first hearing in the case took place at the Federal Court on Friday. Justice Michael Lee ordered that Chubb and the other respondents, including a number of executives and board members, file their defence to Mr Howell's statement of claim by December 14.

The next case management hearing takes place on December 17.